I decided to watch this powerful but sad film as it was a present I bought my sister (on request) for Christmas 2007. We both saw the film back in 1983 in a cinema on a North Sea Ferry but I'd forgotten a lot of the content over the intervening 26 years.
My sister seemed to have been a fan of Frances Farmer ever since then: the actress grew up in Seattle in the 1930s and got a break as an actress in Hollywood. She was naturally rebellious and speaking her mind from her teens onwards generated enemies. There were some sweet romantic scenes as she struck up friendships with local lad Harry York and then a passionate theatre director who embraced non-conformity. Her fall out with the movie machine had major repercussions and they used all their weight to try to force her into line. Her mother, with dreams of her daughter succeeding where she had failed, may have started off well-meaning but her desire to control reminds me of what has recently happened to a well known US singer who found fame when very young but who last year had reportedly become ward of court of her father and lost all rights as an adult. Frances' increasingly desperate and fearsome mother had similarities with the mother in the film 'Virgin Suicides'.
I remembered the last part of the film from the first viewing: it's truly awful what happened to her. She bad accused her mother of wanting to break her spirit but that is exactly what the institution she was taken to eventually succeeded in doing. Jessica Lange, who played Frances conveys the high-spirited, feisty, often angry young woman and her transformation. Harry York meets her years later and discovers how cold, how emotionally blunted she has become. Regardless of her supposed personality disorder the solution taken was utterly brutal. Stanley Kubrick posed a similar question in 'Clockwork Orange', but it was even less morally justified with this poor actress, who simply wanted to escape the system she found herself trapped in.
There is a disclaimer in the credit role in which California's mental health authorities say the deplorable treatment of Ms Farmer in the 1940s is very different from how psychological conditions are dealt with today. This film pre-dates directors commentaries which is a pity as I'd like to find out more about how it was made. It's a damn fine film - it has that olde world feel of America in the early to mid 20th century; it's full of pathos, with wonderful acting by Jessica Lange, Kim Stanley (her mama) and Sam Shepherd (York). It's 'Girl, Interrupted' but set 3 decades earlier. I really like it a lot. 9/10.